Bernard Law P.C.

Estate Planning Blog Articles

Book your Free Estate Planning Consultation Today

Book an Initial Call Now
Can a Family Member Challenge a Trust Created Shortly Before Someone Dies?
Daniel Bernard

Can a Family Member Challenge a Trust Created Shortly Before Someone Dies?

October 28, 2026
If someone creates or changes a trust shortly before passing away, their family might wonder if the trust truly reflects their wishes. This is especially true if the person was seriously ill, had memory problems, or relied on someone who benefits from the trust. In New York, a trust made shortly before death is not […]

If someone creates or changes a trust shortly before passing away, their family might wonder if the trust truly reflects their wishes. This is especially true if the person was seriously ill, had memory problems, or relied on someone who benefits from the trust. In New York, a trust made shortly before death is not automatically invalid, but certain situations can be grounds for a legal challenge. If you believe a trust was created because of undue influence, fraud, or lack of mental capacity, you may have the right to ask a court to review it. At Bernard Law P.C. in Suffolk County, New York, we help families understand trust laws, review questionable estate planning decisions, and decide if a legal challenge makes sense.

New York Law Allows Challenges to Trusts Created Shortly Before Death

In New York, adults who are mentally capable can create trusts and decide how their property will be given out. However, the way a trust is created can sometimes raise questions about whether it is valid.

Under New York Estates, Powers and Trusts Law (EPTL) § 7-1.17, a lifetime trust must satisfy specific execution requirements. Generally, the document must be in writing and properly acknowledged or executed before two witnesses. If the creator is not the sole trustee, at least one trustee must also execute the document as required by the statute.

A trust created days or weeks before death may still be enforceable if these requirements are satisfied and the creator acted voluntarily with sufficient mental capacity. However, evidence of improper influence or questionable execution may support a challenge.

Lack of Mental Capacity May Provide Grounds for Challenging a Trust

One common reason families challenge a trust is concern about the creator’s mental capacity when the document was signed.

A person suffering from dementia, serious illness, confusion, or medication-related cognitive impairment may have difficulty understanding important financial decisions. However, a medical diagnosis alone does not establish that a trust is invalid.

We examine whether the individual possessed the legally required capacity to understand the nature and consequences of creating the trust at the time of execution. The applicable capacity standard depends on the trust transaction and circumstances.

Medical records, physician observations, witness statements, and communications surrounding the signing may help establish whether the creator understood the arrangement. Evidence of significant cognitive impairment close to the execution date can be particularly relevant.

Undue Influence May Invalidate a Trust

Undue influence occurs when another person improperly controls someone’s decisions and causes that person to act contrary to their independent wishes.

For example, an elderly parent may depend on one adult child for transportation, medical appointments, financial management, and daily care. If that child pressures the parent into creating a trust that substantially benefits the child while excluding other relatives, the circumstances may justify investigation.

We examine whether the alleged influencer isolated the individual, controlled access to legal counsel, participated in preparing the trust, or exercised pressure over financial decisions.

Importantly, a close relationship or an unequal inheritance does not automatically establish undue influence. The evidence must support the legal claim that improper influence affected the trust’s creation.

Fraud and Improper Execution Can Also Support a Challenge

A trust may also be challenged when someone uses deception to obtain another person’s signature or misrepresents the contents of a document.

For example, a family member might tell an elderly relative that a document merely authorizes assistance with financial management when it actually transfers substantial assets into a trust benefiting that family member.

We also review whether the trust satisfies EPTL § 7-1.17 and whether its assets were properly transferred.

Under EPTL § 7-1.18, a lifetime trust is valid as to assets transferred into it. Certain property, including real estate and financial accounts, requires appropriate transfer documentation or registration. A signed trust document alone does not necessarily establish that every intended asset became trust property.

Family Members Must Establish Their Legal Interest in the Trust

Not every relative has the legal right to challenge a trust merely because they disagree with its provisions.

Generally, someone pursuing a challenge must demonstrate a legally recognized interest that may be adversely affected by the trust.

This may include an existing beneficiary, a beneficiary under an earlier estate planning arrangement, or an heir who would receive property if the challenged disposition were invalid.

Under New York Surrogate’s Court Procedure Act (SCPA) § 207, Surrogate’s Courts have jurisdiction over qualifying lifetime trust proceedings. The appropriate court depends on factors including the location of trust assets, the creator’s domicile, and the trustee’s residence or principal office.

SCPA § 2101 also addresses proceedings brought by interested persons within the court’s jurisdiction.

Evidence Can Determine Whether a Trust Challenge Succeeds

Trust litigation frequently depends on what occurred before and during the signing process.

We review earlier wills and trusts, medical records, financial transactions, correspondence, and the circumstances surrounding the attorney’s involvement.

Changes that substantially benefit a caregiver or previously uninvolved relative may raise legitimate questions. However, courts also recognize that individuals have the right to change their estate plans, including shortly before death.

The central issue is whether the challenged trust was legally created and reflected the individual’s independent wishes.

Florida Law May Also Affect Trust Disputes Involving New York Residents

Some Suffolk County families own property in Florida or have relatives who maintain residences in both states. These circumstances can raise additional questions about which state’s laws govern a particular trust dispute.

Under Florida Statutes § 736.0402, a valid trust must satisfy several requirements, including the creator’s capacity and intent. Florida Statutes § 736.0406 provides that trust provisions procured through fraud, duress, mistake, or undue influence are void.

Additionally, Florida Statutes § 736.0601 applies the testamentary capacity standard to creating, amending, or revoking a revocable trust.

When a trust involves property or connections in both New York and Florida, we examine the governing documents, applicable laws, and jurisdictional requirements before evaluating the available legal options.

Frequently Asked Questions About Challenging a Trust in New York

Can a Trust Be Challenged If It Was Signed Only Days Before Death?

Yes. New York law does not automatically invalidate a trust because it was created shortly before the creator died. However, the timing may warrant closer examination, particularly when the person was hospitalized, receiving intensive medical treatment, or experiencing cognitive difficulties.

We examine whether the individual had sufficient mental capacity, understood the document, and acted independently. Evidence surrounding the actual signing date is especially important because the individual’s condition may have changed significantly during the final weeks of life.

Can Adult Children Challenge a Trust That Excludes Them From an Inheritance?

Potentially. Adult children do not have an automatic right to inherit their parent’s property through a trust. A parent generally may choose to leave assets to selected individuals or organizations.

However, an excluded child may have grounds to challenge a trust if the child has legal standing and evidence supports a claim involving undue influence, fraud, incapacity, or improper execution. We review earlier estate planning documents and applicable inheritance rights to determine whether the child has a legally recognized interest.

Does a Dementia Diagnosis Automatically Make a Trust Invalid?

No. A dementia diagnosis does not automatically establish that a person lacked the legal capacity to create a trust. Some individuals retain sufficient understanding to make valid decisions despite cognitive impairment.

We examine medical records, cognitive evaluations, witness testimony, and the person’s condition when the trust was executed. The timing and severity of impairment are important considerations. A person who experienced confusion on one occasion may still have possessed sufficient capacity at another time.

How Long Does Someone Have to Challenge a Trust in New York?

The deadline depends on the nature of the claim, the requested relief, and the circumstances surrounding the trust. Unlike certain will contests, lifetime trust challenges do not necessarily follow one uniform filing deadline.

Different statutes of limitations may apply to claims involving fraud, property recovery, fiduciary misconduct, or requests to invalidate a trust. We recommend evaluating suspected problems promptly because delays can affect legal rights, evidence preservation, and the availability of trust assets.

What Happens If a Court Determines That a Trust Is Invalid?

If a court invalidates a trust or particular provisions, the affected property may become subject to a previous valid trust, an existing will, or applicable intestacy rules. The result depends on the specific documents and the court’s findings.

In some cases, only certain transfers or amendments are invalidated rather than the entire trust. We examine the relationship between the challenged document and earlier estate planning arrangements to identify the potential consequences for beneficiaries and heirs.

Can a Trust Be Challenged Before the Person Who Created It Dies?

Sometimes, but challenges during the creator’s lifetime involve additional legal restrictions. A competent person generally retains significant control over a revocable trust and may be able to amend or revoke it.

Family members ordinarily cannot challenge a trust merely because they dislike its terms. However, concerns involving incapacity, exploitation, or financial abuse may justify other protective legal proceedings. We evaluate the person’s capacity, the trust provisions, and the requesting individual’s legal authority before recommending action.

Speak With Our Shoreham Estate Planning Attorney About a Disputed Trust

A trust created shortly before someone’s death can raise serious concerns about mental capacity, financial pressure, and the true intentions of the deceased. These disputes often involve complicated family relationships, significant property interests, and important legal questions that require careful consideration.

At Bernard Law P.C., we help individuals and families evaluate disputed trusts, understand their inheritance rights, and determine the appropriate legal response under New York law. We believe families deserve clear explanations, careful legal analysis, and practical guidance when questions arise about an estate planning document.

If you believe a family member created or changed a trust shortly before death under suspicious circumstances, we can help you assess the situation and understand your legal options.

Contact our Suffolk County estate planning attorney at Bernard Law P.C. by calling (631) 378-2500 to schedule a free consultation. Our law office is located in Shoreham, New York, and we serve individuals and families throughout Suffolk County. We can review the circumstances surrounding the trust, explain the applicable New York estate planning laws, and help you determine whether there are legitimate grounds to challenge its validity.

author avatar
Daniel Bernard
Book an Initial Call Now
Share This Post
Bernard Law P.C. Estate Planning and Administration
Powered by
chevron-down linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram